WhatsApp Secures Landmark Ruling Against Pegasus Spyware in Hacking Lawsuit

Background of the Case

In a legal battle between WhatsApp Inc. and NSO Group Technologies Limited, the court has issued an order regarding motions for summary judgment, sanctions, and discovery. The case began when WhatsApp filed a lawsuit on October 29, 2019, alleging that NSO Group used WhatsApp’s system to send malware to approximately 1,400 mobile phones and devices. The purpose of this malware was to infect the devices and surveil their users. WhatsApp’s complaint included four causes of action, which were: (1) violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA); (2) violation of the California Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (CDAFA); (3) breach of contract; and (4) trespass to chattels. The court dismissed the fourth cause of action, leaving only the first three as operative claims.

Key Technologies and Allegations

The court order explains some of the technical aspects of the case. WhatsApp uses a “signaling server” to create initial connections between users and then a “relay server” to send communication data. NSO Group’s software, called “Pegasus,” uses a modified version of WhatsApp, referred to as the “WhatsApp Installation Server” (WIS). The WIS sends “cipher” files with “installation vectors” to surveil target users. WhatsApp alleges that NSO Group’s actions violated the CFAA, the CDAFA, and constituted a breach of contract.

Motions and Legal Standards

Both parties filed motions for summary judgment. WhatsApp sought a finding of liability on all claims, while NSO Group moved to dismiss or for summary judgment based on a lack of personal jurisdiction and on the merits of the claims. WhatsApp also requested sanctions against NSO Group based on their conduct during discovery. The court applied the standard for summary judgment, indicating that it is appropriate when there is no genuine dispute of material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

Jurisdictional Issues

NSO Group argued that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over them. They cited previous cases where similar lawsuits were dismissed due to a lack of personal jurisdiction or forum non conveniens. However, the court noted a key distinction: the plaintiffs in those cases were foreign citizens, while WhatsApp is a U.S. citizen and a resident of the district. The court concluded that NSO Group did direct its conduct at WhatsApp’s servers, many of which are in California, supporting personal jurisdiction. The court pointed out that the evidentiary record is consistent with a prior conclusion that NSO Group caused a “digital transmission to enter California”.

Sanctions for Discovery Misconduct

The court found that NSO Group failed to produce Pegasus source code in a usable manner. NSO Group had been ordered to produce the full functionality of the spyware, not just the installation layer. The court also noted that NSO Group limited production such that it was viewable only by Israeli citizens in Israel, which was deemed impractical. As a result, the court granted WhatsApp’s motion for sanctions and stated it would impose evidentiary sanctions. One sanction was that the court would conclude that the use of WhatsApp’s California-based servers was a purposeful choice by NSO.

Merits of the Claims

The court granted summary judgment in favor of WhatsApp on all three claims. For the CFAA claim, the court concluded that NSO Group exceeded authorized access by obtaining information from the target users’ devices through WhatsApp’s servers. For the CDAFA claim, the court relied on the evidence regarding California relay servers and the evidentiary sanction regarding targeting of the servers. The breach of contract claim was based on the violation of WhatsApp’s terms of service. The court found that NSO Group’s reverse-engineering and decompiling of WhatsApp software violated these terms.

Next Steps

Since the court has resolved all liability issues, a trial will proceed solely on the issue of damages. The court also instructed the parties to address any expert-related motions and to file an omnibus motion to seal documents.

Post navigation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Rising Role of Artificial Intelligence in Model Risk Management

Financial Institutions Race to Meet DORA Compliance as Deadline Approaches

The CrowdStrike Outage: What Happened and How to Prepare for Future IT Issues

Quantum Computing: Is Google’s Willow About to Shatter Bitcoin?